Pound-for-Pound Explained: What the Lists Measure and What They Can't
Pound-for-pound lists ask who would be best if everyone were the same size. Here is what that question measures, where it fails, and how we read it.
Writer · Rankings and scoring
Born in Gdańsk and living in Melbourne, Tomasz is a data analyst who scores every fight he watches and compares his cards with the judges’.
Writes about: Rankings, Scoring, Fight statistics.
Pound-for-pound lists ask who would be best if everyone were the same size. Here is what that question measures, where it fails, and how we read it.
10-9, 10-8, deductions and split decisions: how pro boxing judges score each round and how three cards combine into a result.
Résumé, recency, head-to-head, activity and losses in context: the factors behind our rankings, how much each counts, and why the lists are our own.
We rescore Sugar Ray Leonard vs Marvelous Marvin Hagler, 1987, round by round, and explain why three judges saw one fight three different ways.
How MMA judges score a round under the Unified Rules: the criteria hierarchy, what earns a 10-8, and why takedowns and control time alone do not win.